Pizza Map›Staten Island

Borough Guide

Best Pizza in Staten Island

Staten Island is the bar pie borough.

That means thin, crisp pies cooked in a small round pan and built to go with a drink. You barely see the style across the harbor, but here it's everywhere. Port Richmond is the anchor, and most places lean toward sit-down, family-run rooms rather than counter slices. There are fewer pizzerias than in the other boroughs, but more of them are worth the ferry.

Explore the Map Browse All 35
An orange Staten Island Ferry crossing the harbor under a clear blue sky

Editor’s Choice

Start With These Three

See them on the map
Joe & Pat's storefront

Classic Slice Castleton Corners

Joe & Pat's

Staten Island's most-cited answer to "why would you go to Staten Island for pizza."

1758 Victory Blvd

Lee's Tavern storefront

Bar pie Dongan Hills

Lee's Tavern

It looks like a bar inside and out, and it is, but this bar happens to make one of the best pies in New York City. Super thin, crunchy bar pie.

60 Hancock St

A pie at Denino's

Bar pie Port Richmond

Denino's

In crust we trust since 1937 — thin, crispy bar pies in a Port Richmond tavern that's barely changed in decades.

524 Port Richmond Ave

Explore

Pizza Map of Staten Island

35 spots

Open full map

Tap a pin for details

Go Neighborhood by Neighborhood

Staten Island Guides

North Shore The ferry's worth it for these alone. View Guide Great Kills Sit-down spots worth the drive from anywhere on the island. View Guide

The Complete Directory

Every Staten Island Pizzeria

Search all 35 when you need the full list.